I found a youtube video of an interview of Michela Wrong by reason.tv in which she talks about
It's Our Turn to Eat. She highlights some interesting things in her book. When asked about Africa and development, she says that the Jeffrey Sach's school of thought, meaning Africa just needs more aid, has been quite popular and the political instability and corruption has been largely downplayed and viewed as irrelevant. Then she asserts that "you cannot pretend to help a country if you don't cast a very critical eye on the politics of the day". I think this makes sense. When foreign aid filters through a country's government from say the IMF or World Bank it does little or no good if that government if corrupt.
Then she affirms something we have talked about in class several times. When asked what the best thing the West could do to help out Africa progress she said, "At the end of the day it's not going to be Western hands, and that's something we need to recognize, and that's something we haven't wanted to recognize....we can't make an African administration do the right thing."
I think it is very important to understand that our hands are tied in some ways and concern ourselves more with our influence rather than our actions when it comes to governments.
I really liked the quote from Wrong that you posted: "You cannot pretend to help a country if you don't cast a very critical eye on the politics of the day." As we continue discussing the issues that arise in international development, I realize more and more that politics is a crucial part of development. Not only would a corrupt government hinder the deliverance of aid within the targeted country, but Western political strings also dictate which aid goes where, often resulting in too much aid in one place and not enough aid where it's really needed.
ReplyDeletePorter, great point about Western politics. I was really surprised at the graph Shannon showed us last week about where most of US aid goes. Very little of US aid went to the countries with the most need. Instead, it went to the countries with the most political interest.
ReplyDelete